剧情简介
The last time Britain was a major force in world cinema was in the 1960s; a documentary of a few years back on the subject was entitled 'Hollywood UK'. This was the era of the Kitchen Sink, social realism, angry young men; above all, the theatrical. And yet, ironically, the best British films of the decade were made by two Americans, Richard Lester and Joseph Losey, who largely stayed clear of the period's more typical subject matter, which, like all attempts at greater realism, now seems curiously archaic.'King and Country', though, seems to be the Losey film that tries to belong to its era. Like 'Look Back in Anger' and 'A Taste of Honey', it is based on a play, and often seems cumbersomely theatrical. Like 'Loneliness of the long distance runner', its hero is an exploited, reluctantly transgressive working class lad played by Tom Courtenay. Like (the admittedly brilliant) 'Charge of the Light Brigade', it is a horrified, near-farcical (though humourless) look at the horrors of war, most particularly its gaping class injustices.Private Hamp is a young volunteer soldier at Pachendaele, having served three years at the front, who is court-martialled for desertion. Increasingly terrorised by the inhuman pointlessness of trench warfare, the speedy, grisly, violent deaths of his comrades and the medieval, rat-infested conditions of his trench, he claims to have emerged dazed from one gruesome attack and decided to walk home, to England. He is defended by the archetypal British officer, Captain Hargreaves, who professes disdain for the man's cowardice, but must do his duty. He attempts to spin a defence on the grounds of madness, but the upper-crust officers have heard it all before.This is a very nice, duly horrifying, liberal-handwringing, middle-class play. It panders to all the cliches of the Great War - the disgraceful working-class massacre, while the officers sup whiskey (Haig!) - figured in some charmingly obvious symbolism: Hargreaves throwing a dying cigarette
影评 (全部26)
壓抑陰暗的反戰電影,也是DB自己最愛的作品,Tom Courtenay的演技不錯/
壓抑陰暗的反戰電影,也是DB自己最愛的作品,Tom Courtenay的演技不錯/
对牺牲少数服务于多数的政治的控诉。可以说是批判意识最强的罗西电影。因为审判的重头戏,台词和特写都较其他作品大幅度增加。审判之中不断插入士兵们对兵营老鼠的戏虐审判,讽刺和隐喻意味不言自明。关于博加德的演技,在站定后到移动的瞬间,上半身小幅度摆动,可以说其最大特点。《召使》中为极致。
对牺牲少数服务于多数的政治的控诉。可以说是批判意识最强的罗西电影。因为审判的重头戏,台词和特写都较其他作品大幅度增加。审判之中不断插入士兵们对兵营老鼠的戏虐审判,讽刺和隐喻意味不言自明。关于博加德的演技,在站定后到移动的瞬间,上半身小幅度摆动,可以说其最大特点。《召使》中为极致。
战争要求士兵保持一种非常状态,你能判一个表现出软弱常态的士兵有罪吗?话剧改编片,导演克制,表演精湛,选长跑者的孤独那个男主演被告很合适,面相单纯又有点可怜。
战争要求士兵保持一种非常状态,你能判一个表现出软弱常态的士兵有罪吗?话剧改编片,导演克制,表演精湛,选长跑者的孤独那个男主演被告很合适,面相单纯又有点可怜。
最荒谬的是,急匆匆判Hamp死刑仅仅是因为上头要派他们这个营次日凌晨六点出发增援前线蒙斯特燧发枪手团的一个营,为了鼓舞士气,所以要赶着出发前执行枪决。然而真能鼓舞士气?恐怕没人相信。而一个年轻的被战争苦难摧残的生命就这样被轻轻易易抹掉了,像牲口老鼠一样在泥水中死去。战争机器里没有人。
最荒谬的是,急匆匆判Hamp死刑仅仅是因为上头要派他们这个营次日凌晨六点出发增援前线蒙斯特燧发枪手团的一个营,为了鼓舞士气,所以要赶着出发前执行枪决。然而真能鼓舞士气?恐怕没人相信。而一个年轻的被战争苦难摧残的生命就这样被轻轻易易抹掉了,像牲口老鼠一样在泥水中死去。战争机器里没有人。
7/10。一队夸张的士兵从死马腹中取出老鼠、扔在水中以击石淹死老鼠,长官营内的镜子绑绳割裂开辩护人的脸,他们给犯人酒精和吗啡缓解精神暴力,行刑队故意把枪口抬高由辩护人亲自补上一枪,想起开头战争纪念墙的长镜头切到炮弹落下,代表正义的军事法庭直接否认污泥中那些腐烂尸首生前遭受的动物异化。
7/10。一队夸张的士兵从死马腹中取出老鼠、扔在水中以击石淹死老鼠,长官营内的镜子绑绳割裂开辩护人的脸,他们给犯人酒精和吗啡缓解精神暴力,行刑队故意把枪口抬高由辩护人亲自补上一枪,想起开头战争纪念墙的长镜头切到炮弹落下,代表正义的军事法庭直接否认污泥中那些腐烂尸首生前遭受的动物异化。
When I am buried, all my thoughts and actsWill be reduced to lists of dates and facts,And long before this wandering flesh is rottenThe dates which made me will be all forgotten——John Masefield
When I am buried, all my thoughts and actsWill be reduced to lists of dates and facts,And long before this wandering flesh is rottenThe dates which made me will be all forgotten——John Masefield
拼尽全力后的一败涂地。难过。Dirk 把那种挣扎矛盾的心境表现得很精准。?
拼尽全力后的一败涂地。难过。Dirk 把那种挣扎矛盾的心境表现得很精准。?
庭辩戏本身就很不错,中间还穿插几段士兵无聊逗弄老鼠的戏形成很妙的对应。这部可以排我最喜欢的“一战题材电影”前五,罗西应该是我喜欢的导演前50,甚至会有前30吧,没排过。Hargreaves辩护军官这个角色,甚至不亚于博加德在《受害者》里的那个律师。
庭辩戏本身就很不错,中间还穿插几段士兵无聊逗弄老鼠的戏形成很妙的对应。这部可以排我最喜欢的“一战题材电影”前五,罗西应该是我喜欢的导演前50,甚至会有前30吧,没排过。Hargreaves辩护军官这个角色,甚至不亚于博加德在《受害者》里的那个律师。